Recently in a discussion we were looking at what an author said, and I was trying to point out the difficulties I had. I felt like we were at least making some progress because we had the book open and we were reading a paragraph out of it. Then I pointed out a phrase which had the word “unique” in it. At that point, the smoke screen began. I was asked what does unique mean? I was told we needed to flesh this out.
Now I don’t know about you, but two college educated, theoretically mature people facing each other across the table needing to flesh out the meaning of “unique” seems bizarre. Is this word really so unusual that we need to spend time defining it? But OK. I was ready to go there. The problem is it was just a smoke screen. He didn’t want to define the word unique. He wanted to change the subject, and he very methodically moved us away from what we were discussing to one of his pet topics.
My point is not that we don’t need to define words. We do. We need to understand and agree on what words mean. And sometimes it is necessary to ask the question that Bill Clinton asked, “It all depends on what the meaning of “is” is.” Sometimes that’s nothing but a smoke screen; other times it is an important consideration.
So yes, definitions are important. But they are only important if there is a serious misunderstanding of what they could mean or a unique context, which makes them have a different understanding. I acknowledge that both of these things can be true. I am also aware that many people when they discuss things are not looking for truth, they’re just looking for validation.
So discuss things in good faith but always be ready to point out the fact that the other person is not. Always be ready to go back and ask the original question again and try to start down a path of discernment. More vital, always be ready to give up if it’s not worth the effort.
homo unius libri
Welcome to Varied Expressions of Worship
Welcome to Varied Expressions of Worship
This blog will be written from an orthodox Christian point of view. There may be some topic that is out of bounds, but at present I don't know what it will be. Politics is a part of life. Theology and philosophy are disciplines that we all participate in even if we don't think so. The Bible has a lot to say about economics. How about self defense? Is war ethical? Think of all the things that someone tells you we should not touch and let's give it a try. Everything that is a part of life should be an expression of worship.
Keep it courteous and be kind to those less blessed than you, but by all means don't worry about agreeing. We learn more when we get backed into a corner.
This blog will be written from an orthodox Christian point of view. There may be some topic that is out of bounds, but at present I don't know what it will be. Politics is a part of life. Theology and philosophy are disciplines that we all participate in even if we don't think so. The Bible has a lot to say about economics. How about self defense? Is war ethical? Think of all the things that someone tells you we should not touch and let's give it a try. Everything that is a part of life should be an expression of worship.
Keep it courteous and be kind to those less blessed than you, but by all means don't worry about agreeing. We learn more when we get backed into a corner.
Opus 2026-442: The Definition of Smoke Screen
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
-
Today in the parking lot I was getting ready to pull into an empty spot but just before I started in I noticed that there was one of those s...
-
At various times in my life I have found myself quoting these verses, (1Ch 16:22 KJV) Saying , Touch not mine anointed, and do my prophets...
-
Today I saw a bumper sticker that said, “Actually, guns do kill people.” I had nothing to write on so I was not able to respond. I wanted t...
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are welcome. Feel free to agree or disagree but keep it clean, courteous and short. I heard some shorthand on a podcast: TLDR, Too long, didn't read.